Wednesday, 2 October 2013

Tigers Over Cardinals in a Tightly Contested World Series Battle

The MLB playoffs are the most exciting, most unpredictable in all of sports.

Consider last year when the San Francisco Giants were down 0-2 against the Cincinnati Reds in a best-of-five series, they stormed back to win three straight games, en route to their second World Series championship in three years.

After falling down 0-2, we can agree very few people would have picked the Giants to rally and take the NLDS, let alone the entire World Series.

There are so many different variables involved in winning a Major League Baseball series that the randomness shouldn’t be all that surprising. Consider a team whose ace and number two pitchers are required to pitch the final two games of the regular season just to earn a spot in the playoffs. This team would be forced to run out their lower-tier starters against the aces of the opposing team. The top-to-bottom talent of both teams all of a sudden becomes obsolete and all that matters in the moments of a high pressure playoff games are the abilities of the two teams’ starting pitchers.

That’s just one example of the entropy of the MLB playoffs, which makes playoff predictions all-the-more challenging and, often, ridiculous. Here, I’ll try to dissect the head to head battles and determine which teams are best poised to take home the hardware.

(At the time of this post, the Pirates had already taken down the Reds in the NL Wild Card game. I had made my predictions for all the series prior to the game yesterday on my twitter feed)

AL Wild Card

Tampa Bay Rays @ Cleveland Indians

Alex Cobb, arguably the most consistent starting pitcher the Rays ran out over the course of the season, gets the ball against rookie Danny Salazar. The Rays have won back-to-back must-win games and are in position to make it three in a row against the inexperienced Cleveland team. Defensively, the Rays are as solid as anyone, with Yunel Escobar, Ben Zobrist, Evan Longoria, and Jose Molina at key positions. Offensively, Longoria, Zobrist, James Loney and even Delmond Young have been swinging the bat extremely well, giving the Rays a formidable, if not highly talented line-up.

Cleveland has a strong line-up anchored by Asdrubal Cabrera, Jason Kipnis, Carlos Santana and Nick Swisher. Ultimately, this is a team that expected to contend, but didn’t necessarily anticipate participating in the playoffs this year. They will come up short.

Winner: Rays

NL Wild Card

Cincinnati Reds @ Pittsburgh Pirates

The Pirates sent out the extremely consistent Francisco Liriano to pitch their most important game since 1992, and that was enough for me to pick the Pirates to succeed against the Reds. And really, who didn’t see a Johnny Cueto implosion coming?

Winner: Pirates

ALDS

Rays vs Boston Red Sox

Being a Blue Jays fan, it’s extremely difficult to put in the effort to find the good in the John Farrell-led Red Sox. Unfortunately, once you dive into the team’s composition, it’s hard to dismiss them as a legitimate threat to capture the World Series. The rotation of Clay Buchholz, Jon Lester, John Lackey and Jake Peavy has the potential to be absolutely dominating. The Red Sox line-up is fantastic, with the likes of Dustin Pedroia, David Ortiz, Shane Victorino, and Mike Napoli doing the bulk of the damage against opposing pitchers. Whoever comes out of the Wild Card game will be overpowered by the dynamic offence of the Red Sox, their high-ceiling rotation, and a power-armed bullpen led by the year’s best closer, Koji Uhera.

Winner: Red Sox

Detroit Tigers vs Oakland Athletics

The A’s have won the AL West for two seasons in a row now, so their success can no longer be counted as a fluke. Their line-up, led by MVP-candidate Josh Donaldson, Coco Crisp and Yoenis Cespedes is highly talented, and they keep churning out young, cheap starting pitchers from their farm, allowing them to stay competitive against the inflated payrolls of the Texas Rangers and the LA Angels.

Having said all that, a rotation including the likely Cy Young winner Max Scherzer, Justin Verlander, Anibal Sanchez and Doug Fister is powerful. Having the best hitter in baseball, Miguel Cabrera, doesn’t hurt their chances at dominance, nor does surrounding him with Prince Fielder, Victor Martinez, Austin Jackson and Torii Hunter. Combine that with the defence newly-acquired Jose Iglesias provides at the all-important short-stop position, and the Tigers are in a position to steamroll the competition.

Winner: Tigers

NLDS

Pirates vs St. Louis Cardinals

The Pirates are, frankly, another happy-to-be-here team, this being their first trip to the playoffs since 1992. The Cardinals were the World Series champions in 2011, and are one of the best run organizations in the Major Leagues. Their ability to consistently churn out talent from their farm is virtually unparalleled. Kids like Michael Wacha, Trevor Rosenthal and Shelby Miller are some of the best young pitchers in the league. That combined with the Cy Young-caliber pitcher in Adam Wainwright and an offence consisting of MVP-candidate Yadier Molina, Carlos Beltran, Matt Holliday and Jon Jay, the Pirates have their work cut out for them. I just don’t think they have enough fire power to compete with the Cardinals in a best-of-five series.

Winner: Cardinals

LA Dodgers vs Atlanta Braves

This is a tough one.

I know, I know. 200-million dollar payrolls are hard to bet against. But the Dodgers are missing some of their more potent hitters in Matt Kemp and Andre Ethier, among others. They’re banged up. And I can’t help but predict that Yasiel Puig, as talented and electrifying as he is, will make a boneheaded mistake or two that costs the Dodgers a game.

That might well prove the difference.

Winner: Braves

ALCS

Tigers vs Red Sox

The Tigers’ line-up is filled with All Stars (both present and future) and anchored by the best hitter in baseball. Their rotation boasts at least three perennial Cy Young contenders and a former MVP. Their bullpen is a little on the weak side, but with starters that consistently pitch deep into games, that shouldn’t be too much of an issue. Experience, pitching, and length in the line-up prevail in this match-up.

Winner: Tigers

NLCS

Braves vs Cardinals

Both teams boast starting rotations that are extremely young but extremely talented, a terrifying notion for the other teams in their respective divisions. Having said that, the Cardinals’ rotation is more polished. If the Braves can keep the games close, however, and give the bullpen a lead in the 9th inning, Craig Kimbrel will almost undoubtedly close the door.

The difference in this series, with both teams boasting such deep and dynamic line-ups and young but electric starting pitching, will be the execution of the youngsters in the rotation. Who handles a pitching staff better than Yadier Molina?

Winner: Cardinals.

World Series

Cardinals vs Tigers

This is a battle of young vs old, experience vs inexperience, when speaking about the starting rotations. If you ask me whose future is brighter, I will undoubtedly say the Cardinals have the brightest future. But we live in a “What do you have for me now?” world. The Tigers have the strongest starting pitching in the league. Iglesias has solidified the defence, the line-up is super strong, and they have their disappointing finish to last year’s season fresh in their minds, having been swept by the Giants. The Cardinals will put up a good fight, but the Tigers will find a way to pull through and shine some light on the struggling city of Detroit.

Winner: Tigers.

And naturally, this sets you guys up for a Red Sox/Dodgers World Series.